NEW YORK — A technical issue with the New York Stock Exchange’s opening auction on Tuesday led to more than 80 stocks being briefly halted at the start of trading, sowing confusion among traders about which orders were filled and whether they were at the correct prices.
The NYSE, which is owned by Intercontinental Exchange Inc , said it was still investigating and that traders may want to consider filing for erroneous trade claims. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission also said it was reviewing the issue.
Financial Post Top Stories
Sign up to receive the daily top stories from the Financial Post, a division of Postmedia Network Inc.
By clicking on the sign up button you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. You may unsubscribe any time by clicking on the unsubscribe link at the bottom of our emails or any newsletter. Postmedia Network Inc. | 365 Bloor Street East, Toronto, Ontario, M4W 3L4 | 416-383-2300
The glitch – the most recent in a series since the “flash crash” of 2010 – impacted stocks of major companies including ExxonMobil, 3M, Verizon, McDonald’s Corp, Wells Fargo and WalMart . The companies did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
“What appears to have happened is a technical glitch where all of my opening orders on the NYSE autocancelled even though some of them should have been fulfilled,” said Dennis Dick, trader at Triple D Trading.
“They have corrected that now, but this is going to be a big mess to clean up.”
The exact cost of the fallout from the glitch is unclear, but the cost to brokers and retail traders is likely to be in the eight-figure range, according to a person at a major brokerage who spoke on condition of anonymity because the matter is sensitive.
“Obviously, there were a lot of stocks that had major issues,” said Joe Saluzzi, co-manager of trading at Themis Trading in Chatham, New Jersey. “It’s a bit of a mess.”
Saluzzi said there was “zero failure tolerance” among traders for glitches at the key open and close of trading.
“This is a failure, there is no sugarcoating it,” said Saluzzi. “There are definitely people who are losing money today who are not happy.”
The opening auction gaffe comes as the SEC is considering routing most retail stock orders through auctions, with the aim of getting individual investors better prices.
“The SEC’s plan to make us all cool and groovy with consumer auctions leaves a lot to be desired,” said James Angel, a finance professor at Georgetown University.
“Auctions are a lot more complicated than it looks. Lots of things can go wrong,” said Angel, who helped work on Nasdaq Inc’s auction process.
The NYSE-listed stocks trade on all 16 U.S. stock exchanges, which use the NYSE’s prices.
Saluzzi said that having multiple exchanges does not help in a situation like this as the only place to trade an opening order on a New York Stock Exchange-listed stock is that exchange itself.
The NYSE is the only major U.S. stock exchange that still uses a trading floor, along with electronic trading, a hybrid model the exchange says facilitates price discovery during market opens, closes, and during periods of trading imbalances or instability.
Technical errors at exchanges can erode market confidence.
“I had a few discretionary trades to place but chose to wait an additional 30 minutes or so after things seemed to normalize to be sure there were no issues,” said Seth Hickle, derivatives portfolio manager at Innovative Portfolios in Indianapolis, Indiana.
To hold exchanges accountable for such glitches, the SEC adopted a sweeping set of business continuity and disaster recovery rules called regulation system compliance and integrity (Reg SCI) in 2014.
In March 2018, the NYSE was the first exchange fined under Reg SCI. The $14 million fine partly related to a nearly four-hour trading halt in July 2015 that resulted from a flawed software rollout.
Steve Sosnick, chief strategist at Interactive Brokers and head trader at Timber Hill, said the fact the NYSE was allowing member firms to consider filing for claims was “a tacit acknowledgement that there are customers who were victimized by poor or erroneous executions.”
“I don’t recall this many stocks halted around the open on an otherwise normal day,” said Sosnick. “Something went wrong and the NYSE owes us an explanation.” (Reporting by John McCrank, Chuck Mikolajczak, Carolina Mandl and Doyinsola Oladipo in New York, Douglas Gillison in Washington, and Medha Singh and Amruta Khandekar in Bengaluru; Editing by Megan Davies, Daniel Wallis and Rosalba O’Brien)